*Markdown version of <https://eise.app/about/autostakkert-vs-eise/>*

> AutoStakkert! is the standard for planetary stacking on Windows. Eise.app runs in your browser on any OS with integrated post-processing. Compare features, workflow, and when each is the better fit.

## AutoStakkert! vs Eise.app

Which planetary stacker should you use?

AutoStakkert! (by Emil Kraaikamp) has been the industry-standard planetary stacker for over a decade. The current stable release is AutoStakkert!4 4.0.11 (January 2024); 4.0.13 (February 2025) is a newer beta build. Eise.app is a newer browser-based alternative built for people who want to stack a video without installing anything. This page compares the two honestly so you can pick the right tool for your workflow.

**Short version:** AutoStakkert! is the more mature and battle-tested tool if you're on Windows and comfortable installing native software. Eise.app is the more approachable choice if you're new to planetary imaging, want stacking and post-processing bundled together, work on macOS or Linux without Wine, or want an open-source tool that will keep evolving.

### Feature-by-Feature Comparison

| Feature | AutoStakkert! | Eise.app |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Install required | Yes (Windows binary) | No - runs in browser |
| Native platform | Windows | Any (browser) |
| Mac / Linux support | Wine / VM only | Native (browser) |
| Mobile / tablet | No | Yes (limited) |
| Price | Free | Free |
| Uploads your data | No (local) | No (local, in-browser) |
| Input formats (native) | SER, AVI, FITS, image files | SER, AVI, MP4, MOV, WebM, image sequences, camera RAW |
| MP4 / MOV / HEVC | Requires user to download FFmpeg and place `ffmpeg.exe` next to `autostakkert.exe` | Built in (FFmpeg-WASM bundled, auto-loaded) |
| Phone video (iPhone MOV / Android VFR MP4) | Works only after the FFmpeg drop-in, and some VFR files still need PIPP first | Direct drop-in |
| Alignment points | Yes, mature implementation | Yes |
| Drizzle stacking | Yes (1.5x, 3x) | Yes (1.5x bicubic and pixfrac beta) |
| Integrated post-processing | No (pair with Registax / ImPPG / AstroSurface) | Yes (wavelets, RGB alignment, color) |
| GPU acceleration | Limited | WebGPU (when available) |
| Community / documentation | Large, decade-plus history | New (2026) |
| Open source | No (closed source) | Yes (MIT-style, on GitHub) |
| Development pace | Slow (AS!4 4.0.11 stable Jan 2024, 4.0.13 beta Feb 2025, no releases since) | Active (weekly changes) |
| Beginner-friendly | Powerful, but many settings to learn | Yes - sensible defaults, guided flow |
| Maturity | Battle-tested since 2012 | Beta - active development |

### When AutoStakkert! is the better choice

- **You're on Windows and stacking is your main workflow.** AutoStakkert! is fast, mature, and integrates well with the wider Windows astrophotography ecosystem (SharpCap, FireCapture, Registax).
- **You already know it.** Every tutorial, every YouTube video, every forum thread about planetary stacking references AutoStakkert!. If you have muscle memory for the workflow, there's no urgent reason to switch.
- **You need very large drizzle or very heavy stacks.** A native binary with a full desktop CPU/RAM budget can crunch through frame counts that a browser sandbox will struggle with.
- **You want the most refined alignment-point implementation available.** Emil has spent over a decade tuning AS!, and it shows in edge cases.

### When Eise.app is the better choice

- **You're new to planetary stacking.** Eise.app was designed to work well with defaults. Frame ranking, cropping, alignment, and sensible sharpening are all set up out of the box - you can get to a decent result without knowing what "AP size" or "double stack reference" means yet. Compare to AutoStakkert!, which is powerful but has more settings to learn upfront.
- **You're on macOS or Linux.** No Wine, no CrossOver, no VM. Eise.app runs natively in the browser on Apple Silicon and Linux.
- **You want to try stacking without committing to an install.** Open the page, drop a file, see a result in seconds.
- **You shoot planetary video with a phone or DSLR.** AutoStakkert! reads SER and AVI natively, but MP4, MOV, and HEVC files (typical of iPhone, Android, and mirrorless cameras) only work after you separately download FFmpeg and drop `ffmpeg.exe` into the AutoStakkert! folder. Eise.app has that layer built in - the same phone clip just opens.
- **You want stacking and post-processing in one tool.** Wavelet sharpening, RGB alignment, deconvolution, and color adjustments are built in - no need to save a TIFF and open Registax or ImPPG afterwards.
- **You want long-term insurance against a tool going stale.** Eise.app is open-source under active development. If maintenance ever slows, the code is on GitHub and forkable. AutoStakkert! is closed-source and its blog has been quiet since around 2020 - the app still works well, but if you rely on it heavily and it ever stops running on a future OS update, you'd be stuck.
- **You're stacking on a shared or work computer.** Nothing to install, no admin rights needed.
- **You want to try stacking on mobile.** It's slower and RAM-constrained, but it does work on a modern phone or tablet.

### Technical Differences

**Architecture.** AutoStakkert! is a native Windows application. It has direct access to the file system, full CPU threading, and OS-level memory. Eise.app runs in a browser sandbox: file access is user-initiated, memory is limited (~2-4 GB per tab depending on browser), and processing uses WebGPU compute shaders and WebAssembly. That trade-off buys cross-platform portability at some cost in peak throughput.

**Alignment.** Both tools use alignment-point-based local warping to compensate for atmospheric seeing across the frame. AutoStakkert!'s implementation is the more refined - years of tuning show up in edge cases (very low light, extreme seeing, dense AP grids). Eise.app implements the same core approach with WebGPU-accelerated template matching.

**Post-processing.** AutoStakkert! deliberately doesn't do post-processing - the assumption is you'll pass the stacked output to Registax (wavelets), ImPPG (deconvolution), or AstroSurface for sharpening. Eise.app bundles wavelet sharpening, deconvolution, and RGB alignment into the same session.

**Video file support.** AutoStakkert!3 and AS!4 read SER, AVI, FITS, and image files directly. For MP4, MOV, and HEVC video (typical of iPhone footage, DSLR/mirrorless clips, and Android recordings), AS! shells out to an external `ffmpeg.exe` that the user has to download separately and place in the same folder as the AutoStakkert! executable. Without that step, the file simply doesn't open. Variable-frame-rate MP4s from phones often still need a pass through PIPP first. Eise.app bundles FFmpeg-WASM inside the browser app: any supported video format works on drop without any extra downloads or file management.

**Privacy.** Both tools process your data locally. AutoStakkert! runs on your machine. Eise.app runs in your browser - nothing is uploaded to a server.

### Try Eise.app

The fastest way to compare the two is to run the same SER or AVI through both.

[Try Eise.app in your browser →](https://eise.app/)

### See also

- [Registax 6 vs Eise.app](https://eise.app/about/registax-vs-eise/) - the classic wavelet sharpener compared
- [Planetary System Stacker vs Eise.app](https://eise.app/about/planetary-system-stacker-vs-eise/) - the Python cross-platform alternative
- [Full planetary stacking software comparison](https://eise.app/about/planetary-stacking-software-comparison/) - all eight tools side by side

